4 Positive Dog Training with Treats?

Jack on Deck of SV Angelsea
Jack the Sailing Dog
Dog training is an essential part of responsible pet ownership, and using treats as a training tool has become a popular method among dog owners. While treats can be effective in motivating and rewarding dogs during training sessions, it’s important to understand the pros and cons associated with this approach. In this blog post, we will explore the advantages and disadvantages of using treats as a training aid for your furry companion.

Pros of Dog Training with Treats:

1. Motivation and Positive Reinforcement:

Using treats as rewards during training can be highly motivating for some dogs. The tasty treats serve as positive reinforcement, encouraging them to repeat desired behaviors. This positive association helps create a positive training experience for both the dog and the owner. Let’s face it Food is a natural motivator.
some breeds work better than others with food motivators.

2. Clear Communication:

Treats provide a clear and immediate way to communicate with your dog. By rewarding desired behaviors with treats, you can effectively convey to your dog what you expect from them. This clarity helps dogs understand and learn commands more quickly.

3. Versatility:

Treats come in various shapes, sizes, and flavors, making them versatile for training purposes. You can choose treats that are easy to handle, break into smaller pieces, or even use special treats for specific training tasks. This versatility allows you to cater to your dog’s preferences and dietary needs.

4. Bonding and Trust:

Using treats as rewards during training sessions can strengthen the bond between you and your dog. The positive reinforcement creates a sense of trust and cooperation, enhancing the overall relationship and making training a more enjoyable experience for both of you.
Jack the sailing dog watching the BBQ
Dog training with treats popular method among dog owners.

Cons of Dog Training with Treats:

1. Dependency on Treats:

One potential drawback of using treats for training is that dogs may become overly reliant on them. They may only respond to commands when treats are present, making it challenging to transition to a treat-free training approach. It’s important to gradually reduce treat usage and reinforce behaviors with other rewards, such as praise or playtime.
The real trick is to avoid the bribe. For example if I say down to my dog and he just stands there. I then pull our a cookie and he lays down immediately that’s a bribe. If they know what it means when you have food then they know what it means when you don’t

2. Weight Management:

Frequent treat usage can contribute to weight gain in dogs, especially if the treats are high in calories. It’s crucial to consider the nutritional content of the treats and adjust your dog’s regular meals accordingly to maintain a healthy weight.

3. Limited Focus:

Some dogs may become overly fixated on the treats during training sessions, leading to a lack of focus on the actual commands or behaviors being taught. This can hinder their ability to learn and respond appropriately without treats present. It’s important to gradually wean off treats and reinforce behaviors without relying solely on food rewards.

4. Allergies and Dietary Restrictions:

Certain dogs may have allergies or dietary restrictions that limit the types of treats they can consume. It’s essential to choose treats that are safe and suitable for your dog’s specific needs, ensuring they receive proper nutrition while training.
Using treats as a dog training aid can be an effective and positive way to teach your dog new behaviors and commands. The motivation, clear communication, and bonding opportunities they provide are undeniable advantages. However, it’s important to be aware of the potential drawbacks, such as treat dependency and weight management concerns.

Do I use the popular way of  Dog Training with Treats?

I personally have used treats on a very limited scale. While in the show ring I always  experienced handlers with a pouch full of treats. Guiding their dog with something constantly  in their hand even when it was their time to be observed and judged.  The dog looked totally unhappy and bored if they weren’t being feed.
For me the joy was in the showman ship , I always enjoyed showing my dogs and in turn I wanted the dogs to enjoy being in the ring to “show off” not for food.
As for obedience trials it depended on the dog.  You would train a yorki  differently than a Boarder Collie.
Striking a balance between training  with treats usage and other forms of rewards such as high praise really depends on the dog and how much patience you have.
When I did use a treat it was generally for tricks such a roll over or shake hands. A terrier is a breed that is a bit more stubborn and can be bribed with a good tasting treat.
Over multiple training sessions, give your dog fewer treats when they complete a command to temper their expectations for significant food rewards every time they obey.
I like to give rewards in addition to treats. The rewards before you take your pooch for a walk, ask them to sit or do a trick; this approach establishes that they can earn life rewards with good behavior.

In that case I would use because they  broke up easy to give easily and the dogs loved them.


dogs on sailboat, training with treats
Jack and Billy first mates on Sailboat Angelsea


IF you would like know more about dog food and feeding your dog Best Dog food

This website may be compensated for linking to other sites or for sales of products we link to. Proud Livinwithdog.com is very selective will only link to products it feels will benefit dog owners. 

If you are interested in our lifestyle and travels https://garyfelton.com/

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *